I recognize that Peyton is great, one of THE greats, a firstballot HOFer, all that jazz. But I've seen him make too many panicked throws in playoff games, with the ball usually winding up in Ty Law's hands. I've seen him utterly choke too many times (revisionists blame the Colts' defense for Peyton only having one ring, but how many times have Cols' seasons ended thanks to Manning INTs? More than you think).
Peyton's great. Best ever?